david galbraith's weblog david galbraith's weblog

December 15, 2005
[ Home ]

my recent wists expand »


Don't believe the hype - Wikipedia is OK

To say that Wikipedia is OK, that it is about as accurate as Britannica, not fantastically better or worse, is not much of a news story.

Much more melodramatic to say that Wkipedia is a disaster, a threat to civilization, full of lies etc.

The reality is that a system that is open for anyone in the world to try to post a lie, that has only been going for a few years, whose contributors don't get paid has only managed to produce a couple of pretty obscure hoaxes.

The truth is that it is a much more accurate reference tool than the Internet as a whole, than most books and, as has just been suggested in a blind test, its pretty much as accurate as Britannica.

Its true that the Britannica test was only for scientific articles - but to be honest, if anybody seriously believes that topics like history are absolutely objective, then they are hopelessly naiive.

Bottom line - considering the way Wikipedia works, its unbelievably, gobsmackingly successful.

BBC NEWS | Technology | Wikipedia survives research test


bio in FOAF »
this in xml »
(rss 1.0)
(rss 0.91)
my Wists »
one line bio »
<olb> Scottish, based in New York, former architect at Foster and partners, founder Wists, co founder: Moreover, co founder: the Origins Network, co author RSS 1.0 </olb>
other projects »

view postings by category »
archives »
meme machines »

others »